admin, Author at Great Manager Institute®

Last 50 days to participate in the Great People Manager Study®—be among India’s Top Great People Managers™. Participate now.

Manager Transformation at a Leading Global Business Services Provider

Context

Enhance customer satisfaction by fostering a Customer- First Culture among 800+ People Managers through focus on Listening, Thanking, and Developing (LTD).

Scope:

  • 1,000 managers participated in the People
    Manager Effectiveness Survey.
  • 300 managers selected for the Great Manager Certification journey.

Impact:

  • Measurable improvements in leadership effectiveness across
    two survey cycles.
  • Certified Great People Managers™ increased from 41% to 46% in six months.
  • Positive correlation between great managers and improved talent retention.
  • Certified managers outperformed peers in team feedback scores.
  • Attrition rates reduced by 3% among certified managers, while
    non-certified saw a 2% increase.
  • Certified managers drove higher learning hours, fostering a culture
    of continuous growth.

Methodology:

  • Tailored workshops targeting key improvement areas.
  • AI-powered nudges to develop behavioral habits.
  • Focused action plans with curated implementation journeys.
  • Strong sponsorship and active senior leadership involvement.

Boosting Customer Satisfaction at a German Multinational Manufacturing Company.

Objective

Enhance customer satisfaction by fostering a Customer- First Culture among 800+ People Managers through focus on Listening, Thanking, and Developing (LTD).

Solution

Using three key rituals

  • Walkie Talkie (Listening)
  • Wah Bhai Wah (Thanking)
  • Udaan (Developing)
result-casestudy-removebg-preview

The Manager Signal CHROs Should Not Miss

The Great People Manager’s™ Journal

Research on People Manager Effectiveness


The Manager Signal CHROs Should Not Miss

Retention and succession planning often get discussed as two separate priorities.

One sits with talent risk.
The other sits with the leadership pipeline.

But in many organizations, both are shaped by the same group of people:
managers.

At Great Manager Institute®, we compared managers recognized as
Great Manager to Work With® with non-recognized managers.
Across two outcome metrics, one pattern stood out.

Recognized people managers are not just better rated by their teams.
They are more likely to stay, grow, and rise from within.

1. They are 2x more likely to stay

Great Manager to Work With® recognized managers are
2x more likely to stay in the same organization
than non-recognized managers.

That matters because a manager exit is rarely just one resignation.

It affects team trust, continuity, performance rhythm and the emotional stability
of the people reporting to them. When a strong manager stays, the organization
protects more than a role. It protects team confidence.

2. They are 2x more likely to get promoted

Recognized managers are also
2x more likely to get promoted
than non-recognized managers.

For CHROs and L&D leaders, this is an important signal.

The managers most ready for the next level are not always the loudest in the room.
Many are quietly building trust, coaching teams, solving people problems and
delivering outcomes without always being visible in traditional talent reviews.

Recognition helps make that leadership capability visible.

The real takeaway

Great Manager to Work With® recognition is not just a badge.

It is a people-manager intelligence signal.

It helps organizations identify managers who are

more likely to stay longer, rise faster and strengthen the internal leadership pipeline.

For leadership teams thinking about retention, succession, and bench strength,
this is the kind of signal worth paying attention to.


New: A Psychometric Assessment Built For People Managers

Most personality tests do not capture the real test of management:
how a manager behaves under pressure.


Tough conversations.
Competing priorities.
Team conflict.
Performance expectations.
Moments where care and accountability must both show up.

Great Manager Institute® has built a psychometric assessment specifically for
people managers.

Currently in its beta rollout, the assessment helps managers receive a leadership
profile covering their strengths, growth areas, and practical takeaways
they can apply immediately.

It is free for a limited time.

Take the Assessment


What Future-Ready Transformation Really Takes

Enterprise transformation today is not just about adopting new technology.
It is about building organizations where intelligence, innovation, people,
and measurable impact move together.

In this blog, Pankaj Jain, Founder & CEO, Aaseya IT Services,
shares how future-ready enterprises can be engineered through

AI-powered innovation, technology excellence, visionary leadership,
and people-powered growth.

For CXOs, CHROs, and business leaders shaping transformation agendas,
this is a must-read.

Read the full blog

The Manager Signal CHROs Should Not Miss

How Your Managers Are Handling Conflict

Do your managers resolve conflict—or escalate it?

What 40,000+ employee voices say

  • Junior managers: Only 66% employees feel conflicts are handled well; 23% negative, the highest across levels.
  • Middle managers: 69% positive, yet 1 in 5 report unresolved issues.
  • Senior managers: 19% negative—experience alone doesn’t close the gap.

What drives effective conflict resolution

Our driver analysis isolates three levers:

  1. Feedback SharingStructured, timely, two-way feedback that surfaces issues early and reduces ambiguity.
  2. Development FocusManagers who actively build capability and coach individuals lower friction within and across teams.
  3. Balanced WorkloadFair distribution of work and clear prioritisation reduce pressure points that trigger conflict.

Why CEOs should care

Conflict isn’t a “people problem”; it’s a hidden execution cost.

It slows cycle time, erodes customer responsiveness, and damages quality. It should be tracked like any other operating risk.

What CHROs can operationalise

  • Build a conflict heatmap by unit and manager level using leading indicators (feedback safety, workload fairness, time-to-resolution).
  • Replace blanket programs with targeted interventions anchored on the three drivers above.
  • Monitor the perception gap (manager vs. team ratings) as an early-warning signal.

What L&D can make repeatable

  • Institutionalise feedback routines (weekly 10-minute issue-resolution huddles with simple templates).
  • Equip managers with coaching protocols and workload triage methods they can apply in real work.
  • Track time-to-resolution, escalations per 100 FTE, and rework due to conflict—not just satisfaction scores.

Bottom line

Conflict management is a non-negotiable leadership competency at every level. When feedback is systematic, development is active, and workloads are fair, trust rises and unresolved conflicts fall—and execution speeds up.


Want to know if conflict resolution is a challenge for your managers?

If you’d like to see your managers’ strengths and areas for improvement, fill out this quick form.

Get your managers’ assessment done and receive a credible profile for each.

Fill Out the Form


Havells India Ltd x Great Managers to Work With®

Congratulations to all the managers at Havells India Ltd. who have been recognized as Great Managers to Work With® — a distinction earned by surpassing the threshold on our People Management Effectiveness Score.

This recognition is a reflection of what truly matters — the voice of your team.

Your people have spoken, and their feedback celebrates your leadership, care, and impact.

505a2c34-88bb-79f4-b7b6-20e89499fafa

Top Actions of Great Leaders

The Hidden Behaviours That Quietly Build Better Leaders

(And Why the Best Managers Practice Them Daily)

If there’s one truth every CEO, CHRO, and L&D Head eventually arrives at, it’s this:

Leadership is built in the small things—repeated consistently.

It’s the micro-behaviours managers practice every day that shape culture, retention, capability, and performance.

At Great Manager Institute®, we’ve spent years studying these behaviours across 24 subthemes of our Connect–Develop–Inspire © (CDI) leadership model. And something fascinating emerged:

When managers are nudged to perform simple, specific micro-actions daily… their leadership habits shift—measurably and sustainably.

These nudges are not reminders. They are behavior-design triggers, crafted to build muscle memory around what great managers do differently.

And because thousands of managers actively practice and complete these nudges, we now know which behaviours truly “stick.”

Below are the top leadership actions managers across India are practicing most consistently today—and what they reveal about how leadership is evolving.


1) CONNECT

Where Trust Begins & Team Energy is Built

Care for Individual

  • Nudge: “Quiz time! Name one hobby of each of your team members. If you don’t know, find out today.”
  • Why it works: Because the fastest way to psychological safety is personal understanding. Teams open up when they feel seen.

Listening

  • Nudge: “In meetings, ask colleagues to elaborate before sharing your view.”
  • Nudge: “If you interrupt someone today, apologise immediately.”
  • Why it works: These two micro-actions reduce invisible friction dramatically. They reset team dynamics by reinforcing respect, patience, and shared ownership of conversations.

Approachability

  • Nudge: “Ask your team: What were your learnings this week?”
  • Nudge: “Block a 30-minute AMA (Ask Me Anything) session—any question is welcome.”
  • Why it works: Approachable leaders reduce hesitation. Hesitation kills speed. Every CEO feels this ripple effect in execution velocity.

2) DEVELOP

Where Capability Grows & Potential Unlocks

Feedback Sharing

  • Nudge: “Ask a team member: How do you prefer receiving feedback—frequency, mode, and style?”
  • Why it works: Because feedback is not just a skill—it’s a relationship contract. When managers personalise it, performance accelerates.

Development Focus

  • Nudge: “Recommend a book to a team member for their professional growth, set up 30 mins to discuss key learning from the book that can be applied in your business context.”
  • Why it works: Learning cultures don’t form in L&D calendars. They form when managers show they are invested in growth, even in small ways.

3) INSPIRE

Where Accountability Sharpens & Teams Rise

Recognition

  • Nudge: “Share an update with your leadership highlighting the contributions of your team.”
  • Why it works: Managers who advocate for their teams create teams that advocate for the work. Recognition fuels motivation; visibility fuels ambition.

The Bigger Insight for CXOs:

Leadership Transformation Doesn’t Require Big Interventions — Just the Right Ones

These nudges are not theoretical. They are real behaviours practiced daily by thousands of managers, giving us a rare window into:

  • Which leadership actions drive trust fastest
  • Where managers default during pressure
  • What behaviours create stronger teams
  • And how habits—not knowledge—build great leaders

This is the new frontier of leadership development:

Micro-actions → Habit Formation → Culture Shift → Business Outcomes → Micro-actions

This virtuous cycle creates a positive self-image for the manager which makes micro-actions more likely.


Green Agrevolution Pvt. Ltd. (DeHaat) x Great Managers to Work With®

Celebrating DeHaat and its Managers, recognized as Great Managers to Work With®.

We are proud to recognize the incredible leadership and people management skills of the managers from DeHaat who have been featured on this year’s prestigious list.


Registrations for the 2026 Study are Closing Soon!

Want to see yourself—or your managers—featured as:

  • Great Managers to Work With®,
  • India’s Top 100 Great People Managers™, or
  • India’s Top 50 CEOs, MDs, and Founders (2026)?

Click here to learn more

3a86828c-d2cf-60f4-708d-dfd7f6054208

Leadership Effectiveness Across Career Stages

Dear <<First Name>>,

A young manager leading a team of senior employees. An experienced leader managing a team of freshers. Same company, very different stories and our research shows exactly why? Leadership is often seen as one-size-fits-all, but the real story is much more complex—and fascinating.

We analysed employee feedback ratings on their managers’ behaviours across multiple organisations, examining how leadership behaviors resonate with employees of varying career stages. Instead of simply focusing on averages, we analyzed how employees experienced leadership in different contexts—unveiling subtle but powerful insights.

Here’s what we discovered:


Manager Effectiveness: It’s About the Interaction

It turns out that leadership is a dynamic interplay between the manager and their team, not just the leader alone. The same manager may be perceived differently based on the career stage of the team they lead. A leadership style that works well for one team may not work for another, depending on where they are in their careers. This has portfolio implications for manager–team combinations.

Young Teams Love Collaboration, But Need Balance

For early-career employees, collaboration was a standout leadership behavior. In fact, they were 1.27X more likely to report strong collaboration experiences. However, they were also 1.22X more likely to feel their workload wasn’t well-balanced.

This indicates that while young teams thrive in collaborative settings, they require stronger guidance on prioritization and workload management.

Experienced Teams Crave Stability, But May Collaborate Less

When we look at more experienced teams, leadership expectations shift. These teams were 1.16X more likely to report strong experiences with balanced work. But they’re also 1.29X more likely to report weaker collaboration. Basically, the more experienced someone gets, the more they prefer working independently and having a steady, predictable routine rather than the buzz of constant teamwork.

a77bf02d-e4bd-0bbc-b236-495ae2921718

The Key Insight: Leadership Dynamics Vary by Manager-Team Combo

When we analyzed the manager–team age group combinations, four distinct leadership dynamics emerged:

  • Experienced Manager → Young Team: Managers are perceived to be better in Guidance and Taking accountability for the Team’s performance (including mistakes made by the team), reflecting mentorship dynamics.
  • Young Manager → Young Team: Teams report enhanced Collaboration, Influence, and Reliability (keeping commitments made), showing a peer-driven, energetic environment.
  • Young Manager → Experienced Team: Teams experience higher Care for Individuals, Fair Treatment, and demonstrating Competence, where younger leaders build credibility through relational leadership.
  • Experienced Manager → Experienced Team: Experience of the team is better on Balanced Work, but weaker Inter-team Collaboration, perhaps showing better ability in organising work and a distinct preference for autonomy.

Why It Matters

Leadership isn’t a one-size-fits-all concept. Each manager-team combination reveals a unique set of leadership strengths—from mentorship and collaboration to empathy and stability. Understanding these dynamics can empower organizations to match leadership styles with team maturity, ensuring more effective leadership and improved outcomes.

At Great Manager Institute®, we’re committed to helping organizations navigate these leadership challenges and align leadership styles with team needs.

Congratulations to the managers at Tata Starbucks for earning the Great Managers to Work With® recognition, which reflects their exceptional leadership and the impact they’ve had on their teams.

b9656d40-df9c-c679-1030-040d73ba925f

Gen Z is already leading — but are your systems ready?

Hi <<First Name>>,

Very soon (if it hasn’t happened already), a 24–25-year-old will be:

  • Leading a critical team
  • Giving performance feedback to millennials
  • Asking you for faster growth and better balance

The question is no longer “How do we hire Gen Z?”

It’s “How do we let Gen Z lead without breaking our systems?”

From Sep 2024 to Sep 2025, we analysed:

  • Gen Z managers (≤25): ~100 open-text comments about how their teams experience them
  • Gen Z employees (≤25): 500+ survey responses across IT/ITES, BFSI and Manufacturing

A few patterns that should make any CEO/CHRO/L&D head pause:

  • Gen Z managers are strongly supportive… but falter under pressure
  • Recognition is high intent, low system – appreciation exists, but it’s uneven and ad-hoc
  • Middle managers are the “pressure bridge” – they score best on balance, yet carry the highest inconsistency
  • 45–54 age band leaders show the widest expectation gap with Gen Z
  • BFSI & Manufacturing are most at risk on conflict handling, workload fairness, and development clarity

We’ve pulled this into a concise research note with:

  • The 5 leadership moves to wire into your 2026 manager capability roadmap, and
  • Concrete plays for EQ, conflict, recognition, delegation and workload design

Read the full research on Gen Z redefining leadership


Last 48 days left to participate in the Great People Manager Study® 2026!

Registrations are closing soon — don’t miss your chance to:

  • Be among India’s Top 100 Great People Managers™ and feature in the Economic Times
  • Or among India’s Top 50 Great leaders list for CEOs / MDs / Founders

Reply to this email, and our team will help you get registered — or click below to participate now.

Participate now

ab78746c-1318-ea3f-b238-80a1a55c8130

Why Great Leaders Make Time for Fun

Hi <<First Name>>,

At work, celebration isn’t about parties.

It’s about whether people feel seen, valued, and connected.

From our latest research on the statement “My manager creates opportunities to celebrate and have fun together”, here’s what we’re seeing across organizations:

  • Younger & junior managers are your culture engine: Managers in the 26–34 age group and junior bands are the ones consistently calling out effort, celebrating wins, and keeping teams emotionally connected.
  • As seniority rises, celebration quietly disappears: Senior leaders and managers 45+ don’t celebrate less because they don’t care—but because pressure, reviews, and meetings crowd it out. The higher you go, the more intentional the celebration has to become.
  • Hybrid teams celebrate better: Teams that mix in-person and online touchpoints show stronger, more positive experiences of fun and celebration.
  • Fast-paced industries sacrifice celebration first: In BFSI, IT/ITES, Manufacturing, Healthcare, FMCG, and other high-tempo environments, culture moments are often the first to go when timelines hit.

Yet our data suggests: celebration is operational glue—it strengthens trust, collaboration, resilience, and retention.

Your managers don’t need more off-sites. They need small, consistent rituals: a 60-second “good news first” in every meeting, a weekly “win shout-out,” a simple peer spotlight.


The Great People Manager Study® 2026 is closing soon

If you want to recognize and celebrate your managers at a national level, this is the moment.

Through the Great People Manager Study® 2026 you can:

  • Nominate your managers to be featured among India’s Top 100 Great People Managers™ 2026, showcased in The Economic Times (our exclusive media partner).
  • Recognize more of your leaders as Great Managers to Work With®, by putting them through a rigorous, data-backed assessment of how their teams actually experience them.

👉 Participate now to:

  • Benchmark your managers against national standards
  • Identify your real culture builders
  • And celebrate your leaders, publicly, not just in internal meetings

You can recognize and celebrate your managers at a national level—while getting deep insight into how they truly impact culture—by participating in the Great People Manager Study® 2026.

Know More

Growing People. Building Leaders.

Growing People. Building Leaders.

By Pankaj Jain, Founder & CEO, Aaseya IT Services

When people ask me what makes Aaseya special, my answer is always the same—it is our people.

Technology may be what we do, but people are the reason we succeed. Every innovation we create, every customer relationship we build, and every milestone we achieve begins with individuals who are passionate about learning, taking ownership, and making a difference.

Over the years, I have come to believe that the true measure of leadership is not the number of people who report to you, but the number of leaders you help create.

That philosophy has shaped our culture at Aaseya.

I have never believed in creating followers. I believe in creating opportunities for people to think independently, make decisions with confidence, challenge conventional thinking, and take ownership of outcomes. When people are trusted, they surprise you with what they are capable of achieving.

At Aaseya, every voice matters. Some of our best ideas have come from people who work closest to our customers and understand their challenges firsthand. That is why I encourage open conversations through leadership interactions, town halls, feedback forums, and regular employee connect sessions. Innovation grows when people know they are being heard.

Continuous Learning & Future Readiness

One thing I have learnt during my career is that technology never stands still.

Neither should people.

Learning at Aaseya is not a programme or an annual initiative—it is part of our everyday culture.

As an AI-first organization, we are continuously investing in helping our people stay ahead of change. Whether it is certifications across Pega, OutSystems, and Camunda, exposure to Artificial Intelligence, intelligent automation, emerging technologies, or collaborative learning, our objective is simple—to prepare our people for the future, not just for their current role.

I firmly believe that every employee should leave Aaseya more capable than when they joined us.

One initiative that is particularly close to my heart is our Future Leaders Forum. It was designed with a simple purpose—to identify potential early, nurture leadership capabilities, and prepare individuals to take on larger responsibilities. Seeing participants grow in confidence and step into leadership roles reinforces my belief that great leaders are developed through opportunity, trust, and continuous learning.

We are not simply building technical experts.

We are building decision-makers, innovators, mentors, and future business leaders.

People First. Always.

Every organization speaks about people.

For me, it has always been about creating an environment where people genuinely feel respected, trusted, and valued.

A culture cannot be built through policies alone. It is built through everyday conversations, mutual respect, transparency, and empathy.

I want every employee to feel comfortable sharing ideas, asking questions, challenging perspectives, and knowing their voice matters.

That is why open communication remains one of the strongest pillars of our culture. Employee surveys, leadership interactions, skip-level discussions, and continuous feedback help us learn just as much from our people as they learn from us.

When people know they are trusted, they bring their best selves to work.

And when they bring their best, organizations achieve extraordinary outcomes.

Recognition That Inspires Excellence

Recognition should never be limited to an annual ceremony.

The best appreciation happens in the moment.

Whether someone delivers an exceptional customer outcome, earns a difficult certification, solves a complex business problem, or simply goes the extra mile to support a colleague, those efforts deserve to be celebrated.

Through initiatives like our Aaseya Champions Circle, we recognise people who demonstrate innovation, ownership, collaboration, customer commitment, and leadership every single day.

One of my favourite moments is personally congratulating employees for important milestones—whether it is completing an advanced technology certification, receiving customer appreciation, or delivering an exceptional project.

Recognition creates confidence.

Confident people take bigger ownership.

And ownership builds great organizations.

Building Careers, Not Just Roles

One of my greatest aspirations has always been to build an organization where careers flourish and leaders emerge naturally.

I do not want Aaseya to be known only for the technology we deliver.

I want us to be known for the leaders we develop.

Every employee is encouraged to explore new opportunities, broaden their capabilities, and continuously learn beyond their current responsibilities. Through mentoring, collaboration, challenging assignments, and experiential learning, we prepare our people not only for their next role but for long-term success.

One of the strongest indicators of our culture is the number of colleagues who choose to return to Aaseya after exploring opportunities elsewhere. Equally rewarding is seeing many of our former colleagues leading business units, technology practices, and organizations across the industry.

Their success makes us proud because, in many ways, their leadership journey began here.

We have also consciously built one of the youngest leadership teams in our industry, believing that leadership is determined by capability, vision, and values—not by age or tenure.

My hope is that every individual who has been part of Aaseya carries a piece of this culture wherever their journey takes them.

Work Hard. Celebrate Harder.

Building a high-performing organization does not mean forgetting to celebrate.

Some of the strongest teams are built outside meeting rooms.

Whether it is sports tournaments, marathons, cultural celebrations, annual gatherings, volunteering initiatives, family events, or simply coming together to celebrate milestones, these moments strengthen relationships in ways that work alone never can.

People collaborate better when they know one another beyond their job titles.

They innovate better when they enjoy working together.

Culture is built through these shared experiences.

Our Promise

As Aaseya continues to grow across new markets, embrace Artificial Intelligence, and help enterprises transform digitally, one thing will never change.

Our people will always remain our greatest strength.

Technology will evolve.

Industries will transform.

Customer expectations will continue to rise.

But leadership will always be about people.

Success will always be about people.

Culture will always be about people.

That is the legacy I hope Aaseya continues to build.

Not just an organization known for delivering exceptional digital solutions, but one that is remembered for developing exceptional professionals, confident leaders, and responsible human beings.

Because long after projects are completed and technologies evolve, it is the people we have inspired, empowered, and helped grow who will define the true success of Aaseya.

And if every person who has been part of our journey can one day look back and say, “My leadership journey truly began at Aaseya,” I will consider that our greatest achievement.

— Pankaj Jain
Founder & CEO
Aaseya IT Services

How to Measure Manager Effectiveness: The Only Framework CHROs in India Need in 2026

The Problem No CHRO Talks About Openly

You have a performance review system. You have annual appraisals. You probably have a 9-box grid. And yet, when you look at attrition reports, engagement scores, and business unit performance, you know something is still missing.

The missing piece is almost always the same: you are measuring what managers deliver, not how they lead.

And the gap between those two things is costing your organisation more than you think.

At Great Manager Institute®, we found that on an average, managers rate themselves 7 points higher than how their teams rate them. For 4 in 10 managers, that gap is even wider meaning for most teams, the manager’s version of reality and the team’s version of reality are not the same. For example, managers invariably think they are better than how their teams rate them in areas like development focus, seeking suggestions and ideas, fair treatment and listening. (Yes, you read it right, your boss thinks they are far better at listening than what you give them credit for!) It is where disengagement, attrition, and underperformance begin. Yet most organisations in India continue to assess managers primarily on KPI achievement,  and project delivery, and employee experience, while the behaviours that actually drive team performance, retention, and culture go completely unmeasured.

The difference between delivering and leading.

This is the problem this blog will help you solve.

Why Measuring Manager Effectiveness Is Now a Board-Level Priority

For a long time, measuring manager effectiveness felt like a “nice to have” something progressive organisations did, but not a strategic imperative.

That has changed.

In 2025, leader and manager development is the single highest-priority initiative for CHROs globally, according to a survey of 500 CHROs conducted by Gartner. For two consecutive years, it has topped the list above talent acquisition, above digital transformation, above DEI.

Why the urgency? Three forces are converging simultaneously:

  1. The Engagement Crisis Is Getting Worse Global employee engagement fell to 21% in 2024 the lowest level since the COVID-19 pandemic resulting in an estimated $438 billion in lost productivity worldwide. In South Asia (primarily India), manager engagement dropped by 8 percentage points in a single year, the largest regional decline globally. That is the clearest possible signal that measuring engagement is not the same as understanding what drives it. Behind every disengaged team is a set of specific manager behaviours that either built or broke that engagement.
  2. Managers Are Burning Out, Managers today are being asked to navigate more complexity than ever before AI adoption, hybrid teams, leaner resources, and rising employee expectations often without training, data, or structured support. Research by Great Manager Institute® shows one in three CXOs are in high burnout category. When managers are underprepared and unmeasured, their teams feel it first which effect on engagement.
  3. Organisations Are Promoting the Wrong People DDI’s Global Leadership Forecast 2025 found that 82% of organisations promote individual contributors into management roles based on technical skill, not management capability. The result? Leaders who are technically excellent but people-management weak and organisations that discover this only after attrition spikes.

The solution to all three problems starts in the same place: a rigorous, consistent system to measure manager effectiveness.

What “Manager Effectiveness” Actually Means

Before you can measure it, you need to define it and most organisations define it too narrowly.

Manager effectiveness is not the same as manager performance. A manager can consistently hit their numbers while their team is disengaging, underperforming, and quietly job-hunting. Performance metrics tell you what got done. Effectiveness metrics tell you how and whether it’s sustainable.

Genuine manager effectiveness operates across three dimensions:

  1. Connect – Does the manager build trust, psychological safety, and genuine human connection with their team? Do team members feel seen, respected, and heard?
  2. Develop – Does the manager actively build the capability of each team member? Are they having growth conversations, giving feedback, and investing in people’s potential?
  3. Inspire – Does the manager create meaning, direction, and motivation? Do team members understand the bigger picture and feel energised to contribute to it?

This is the Connect-Develop-Inspire (CDI)© framework the proprietary research-backed model developed by Great Manager Institute® after studying thousands of managers and teams across India. It is built on the insight that the best managers don’t just manage tasks; they shape the human experience of work.

The Right Framework: What to Measure, and How

An effective manager measurement framework needs to do four things:

  1. Capture stakeholder feedback – primarily from the people who experience the manager’s leadership daily: their direct reports.
  2. Cover the right competencies – not just task management and goal setting, but the human dimensions of leadership: trust, development, psychological safety, and inspiration.
  3. Produce a comparable score – so you can benchmark a manager against their peers, against their own past performance, and against external industry norms.
  4. Link directly to development – so the assessment is not a verdict, but a starting point for growth.

The 10 Competencies That Matter Most

Based on Great Manager Institute’s® Great People Manager Study® India’s largest study on people management the following competencies are the strongest predictors of team engagement, retention, and performance:

Connect Dimension:
1. Listening
2. Caring
3. Informing

Develop Dimension:
4. Nurturing
5. Improving
6. Involving

Inspire Dimension:
7. Role modeling
8. Celebrating
9. Influencing
10. Accountable

These 10 competencies, measured across 24 sub-dimensions via structured feedback from direct reports, form the backbone of Great Manager Institute’s® People Manager Effectiveness Survey (PMES) which generates a People Manager Effectiveness Score for each manager, complete with internal and external benchmarks.

What Happens When You Don’t Measure Manager Effectiveness

The risks of not measuring are not abstract — they show up on your P&L.

Consider the cost structure:

  • Attrition: Replacing a mid-level professional in India costs an estimated 6–9 months of their salary in recruitment, onboarding, and productivity loss. One disengaged manager driving out two team members per year is a multi-lakh rupee liability.
  • Productivity: Teams with highly effective managers outperform peers by 27% on revenue metrics, according to research data. The productivity gap between your best-managed and worst-managed teams is not a soft metric — it shows up in quarterly results.
  • Culture: Every ineffective manager is actively shaping the culture of the organisation just not in the direction you want. 71% of employees decide to stay or leave their organisation based on their experience with their manager.

The India-Specific Reality CHROs Must Acknowledge

Measuring manager effectiveness in India comes with a specific context that global frameworks often overlook:

Hierarchy is real. In many Indian organisations, direct reports are reluctant to give honest feedback to or about their managers without anonymity guarantees and strong psychological safety signals from leadership.

Tenure ≠ Capability. Long-serving managers are often treated as effective by default. India’s Great People Manager Study® consistently finds that years of experience have weak correlation with manager effectiveness scores — behaviour-based assessment is essential.

Scale is a challenge. Large Indian enterprises often have hundreds or thousands of people managers. Any measurement system must be scalable, consistent, and not dependent on subjective HRBP conversations.

Benchmarks must be local. A manager effectiveness score only becomes useful when it can be benchmarked — and global benchmarks are of limited value. India-specific benchmarks, drawn from assessments across Indian organisations and industries, are what CHROs need to make informed decisions.

These are precisely the gaps that the Great People Manager Study® — now in its 6th edition, covering thousands of managers across Indian organisations — is designed to address.

The Bottom Line: What Great Looks Like

The organisations that consistently develop Great People Managers™ share three structural similarities:

  1. They measure behaviours, not just outputs. KPIs tell you what got done. Manager effectiveness frameworks tell you whether the way it got done is building or destroying your culture and talent pipeline.
  2. They make measurement ongoing, not episodic. Annual reviews create annual blind spots. The best organisations have a pulse on their management quality in near-real-time.
  3. They close the loop between assessment and development. An assessment without a development plan is a diagnosis without treatment. The data must feed directly into personalised, accountable growth journeys for every manager.

If your organisation is still relying on performance appraisals and 9-box grids to understand how well your managers are leading — this is the year to change that.

Ready to Measure What Actually Matters?

Great Manager Institute® has spent years building India’s most comprehensive people manager assessment and development ecosystem — grounded in proprietary research, benchmarked against 100000 Indian managers, and designed to turn data into development at scale.

Explore the People Manager Effectiveness Survey (PMES) →
Talk to Our Team About Manager Effectiveness Assessments →

About Great Manager Institute®: GMI is India’s leading people management research, assessment, and leadership development organisation. Built on the Connect-Develop-Inspire (CDI)© framework and powered by India’s largest study on people management, GMI works with organisations across sectors to assess, develop, and recognise Great People Managers™.

Related Reading: